Wheels Away Logo

America’s Riskiest States for Animal Collisions in 2026 Revealed

|

2,781 words

|

In the last week of October 2026, Americans searched for help after hitting a deer more than in any week for at least five years. And the worst of the season is still to come.

In the US, more than 1.6 million animal-collision insurance claims are made each year – and the overall repair bill is not cheap.

With 41% of animal-collision claims landing between October and December, the risk peaks now. To find out where in the US drivers face the most danger, we ranked all 50 states and Washington DC on 11 measures in our own index, from the odds of a claim and the share of driving on rural roads to road deaths, deer numbers and how often drivers search for help online.

Below, you’ll find the full ranking, what a deer strike really costs, how insurance treats it and what to do if it happens to you.

Key Findings

  • Montana is America’s riskiest state for animal collisions, scoring 68 out of 100, with an animal-crash death rate 7.3 times the national average.
  • West Virginia has the worst odds in the country, at 1 in 46, and the highest repair bill per driver at $95 against $30 nationally.
  • Pennsylvania faces the biggest bill, at an estimated $622 million a year. Texas had the most deaths in 2024 with 20.
  • More than 1.6 million claims are made each year, totalling an estimated $7.2 billion repair bill.
  • The average insurance payout for hitting an animal is up to 88% in under a decade, from $3,176 in 2014 to $5,980 in 2023.
  • 210 people were killed in animal crashes in 2024. That was down from 234 in 2023, the highest since records began in 1975.
  • Searches for “hit a deer” reached a five-year high in the week of October 25-31, 2026.

The Riskiest States for Animal Collisions in 2026, Ranked

Each state’s score combined 11 measures of animal-collision risk into a single figure out of 100, with the odds of a claim and the share of driving on rural roads carrying the most weight. The higher the score, the higher the risk. See how we built the index for the full breakdown.

Where Does Your State Rank?

RankStateIndex score (/100)Odds of a claimState Farm risk bandRural share of drivingAnimal-crash deaths per million (yearly avg)Est. repair bill per driverChange in risk vs last year
1Montana68.01 in 54High71%4.2$81-1.9%
2West Virginia63.11 in 46High57%1.3$95-13.0%
3Wisconsin62.91 in 62High52%2.0$71-6.5%
4Pennsylvania60.31 in 64High37%1.0$68-3.1%
5Michigan55.71 in 68High31%1.2$64-10.3%
6South Dakota50.31 in 86High70%1.9$51-15.1%
7Mississippi49.41 in 81High59%0.9$54-4.9%
8Wyoming48.91 in 96High73%2.2$46-14.6%
9Kansas48.61 in 89High47%1.7$49+15.7%
10Maine48.31 in 85High66%1.0$51+10.6%
11Iowa47.21 in 81High59%1.1$54-6.2%
12North Dakota46.51 in 100High68%1.9$44-9.0%
13North Carolina45.91 in 95High39%0.9$46-3.2%
14Kentucky43.51 in 100High52%2.2$44+5.0%
15Missouri42.51 in 97High45%1.7$450.0%
16Minnesota40.91 in 91High40%1.0$48-5.5%
17Virginia39.91 in 133High30%1.1$54+1.2%
18Oklahoma39.11 in 124Medium49%1.9$35+1.6%
19Vermont38.71 in 133Medium73%0.4$33-18.8%
20South Carolina38.61 in 103Medium38%1.1$42-9.7%
21Ohio38.41 in 108Medium30%0.9$40-2.8%
22Georgia36.11 in 115Medium31%1.0$38-5.2%
23Texas36.11 in 223Low27%0.4$20-0.4%
24Indiana36.11 in 116Low39%1.3$38-6.0%
25Alabama34.41 in 109Medium40%0.6$40+8.3%
26Tennessee34.01 in 129Medium38%1.0$34-6.2%
27Arkansas33.21 in 135Medium47%0.6$32-29.6%
28Idaho31.51 in 159Medium57%0.4$28-3.1%
29Nebraska29.51 in 161Medium53%0.8$27-3.7%
30New Mexico28.71 in 292Low59%1.4$150.0%
31Maryland27.91 in 117Medium20%0.2$37-1.7%
32New York25.11 in 185Medium21%0.3$24-9.7%
33Illinois24.91 in 195Low24%0.5$22-6.7%
34New Hampshire24.41 in 179Medium40%0.6$24+5.6%
35Oregon24.31 in 223Low41%0.6$201.8%
36Delaware23.51 in 152Medium27%0.3$29-10.5%
37Louisiana22.41 in 215Low38%0.4$20+1.4%
38Massachusetts21.21 in 106Medium5%0.1$41+10.4%
39Alaska20.01 in 580Low43%2.0$8+14.0%
40Colorado18.61 in 253Low29%0.6$17+2.0%
41Utah16.81 in 251Low28%0.5$170.0%
42Washington15.61 in 305Low28%0.3$14-0.7%
43Rhode Island14.21 in 193Low10%0.2$23-27.5%
44New Jersey13.51 in 245Low7%0.3$18-7.8%
45California13.11 in 430Low19%0.1$10+2.6%
46Arizona12.21 in 682Low26%0.4$6-15.4%
47Connecticut11.31 in 289Low10%0.2$15-1.7%
48Florida10.61 in 543Low16%0.2$8+5.9%
49District of Columbia8.91 in 635Low0%0.0$7+25.0%
50Nevada8.91 in 838Low21%0.4$5+15.3%
51Hawaii6.11 in 852Low18%0.0$5+6.5%

The Safest States for Animal Collisions

Hawaiian drivers have the least risk of animal collisions, scoring 6.1 out of 100, with odds of a claim coming in at just 1 in 852.

Nevada and Washington DC shared the second-lowest place on the index at 8.9, followed by Florida (10.6) and Arizona (12.2). However, low risk doesn’t mean no risk. Nevada’s odds worsened by 15.3% this year (2026), and DC’s by 25%.

Although Alaska comes in at 39th place, its animal-crash death rate of 2.0 per million residents is more than three times the national average.

The 10 Riskiest States for Hitting a Deer

Montana, West Virginia and Wisconsin are the top 3 riskiest states, according to Wheels Away’s 2026 index.

All of these states score above 62, and only 0.2 points separate second (West Virginia) from third (Wisconsin).

RankStateIndex Score (/100)Odds of a claimRural share of drivingEst. repair bill per driverChange in risk of collision (2024 vs 2025)
1Montana68.01 in 5471%$81-1.9%
2West Virginia63.11 in 4657%$95-13.0%
3Wisconsin62.91 in 6252%$71-6.5%
4Pennsylvania60.31 in 6437%$68-3.1%
5Michigan55.71 in 6831%$64-10.3%
6South Dakota50.31 in 8670%$51-15.1%
7Mississippi49.41 in 8159%$54-4.9%
8Wyoming48.91 in 9673%$46-14.6%
9Kansas48.61 in 8947%$49+15.7%
10Maine48.31 in 8566%$51+10.6%

Top 10 States at a Glance

1. Montana (68.0): America’s riskiest state. Montana has more claims for its size than anywhere else, at 1,422 per 100,000 residents, and 71% of its driving is on rural roads. Its animal-crash death rate is 7.3 times the national average.

2. West Virginia (63.1): The worst odds in the country, at 1 in 46, a spot it has held for more than a decade. Drivers are 3.2 times as likely as the average American to hit an animal and face the highest bill per driver, at $95.

3. Wisconsin (62.9): Wisconsin’s problem is scale. Close to 200 claims a day add up to a $315.6 million bill, and WisDOT recorded more than 17,700 deer crashes in 2025, 3,389 of them in November. Its 13 deaths in 2024 were the fourth-highest in the US.

4. Pennsylvania (60.3): The biggest repair bill in America, at an estimated $622 million a year from around 142,300 claims. Odds are 1 in 64, and Pennsylvania’s 15 animal-crash deaths in 2024 were second only to Texas.

5. Michigan (55.7): The second-biggest bill, at $503 million from around 115,000 claims. Michigan has an estimated 1.85 million deer, the largest herd in the top 10. Together with Pennsylvania, it accounts for more than one in seven US claims.

6. South Dakota (50.3): Seven in ten miles driven in South Dakota are on rural roads, and there are around 0.72 deer for every licensed driver, the third highest ratio in the country. Its animal-crash death rate is more than three times the national average.

7. Mississippi (49.4): Mississippi has almost one deer for every licensed driver (0.84), the second highest ratio in the US, from a herd of around 1.75 million. Odds of a claim are 1 in 81, and 59% of driving is rural.

8. Wyoming (48.9): Wyoming shares the highest rural share of driving in the US with Vermont, at 73%, and has the most deer per driver, at 0.90. Its animal-crash death rate is 3.8 times the national average.

9. Kansas (48.6): Kansas has the fastest-rising risk of any high-risk state. Its odds shortened from 1 in 103 to 1 in 89 in a year, a 15.7% jump. Kansans also searched for help after hitting a deer more than any other state, at 71 searches per 100,000 drivers.

10. Maine (48.3): Maine climbed from 15th to 9th on State Farm’s list as its risk rose 10.6%. Two-thirds of its driving is on rural roads, and it ranks third in the country for search interest in “hit a deer”.

Outside the top 10: Texas sits in State Farm’s low-risk band at 1 in 223, but recorded more animal-crash deaths than any other state in 2024, with 20.

How Much Does It Cost to Hit a Deer?

In 2023, the average insurance payout for hitting an animal was $5,980 in 2023, up from $3,176 in 2014. That’s an increase of 88% in just under a decade.

Claims made in November cost more than the yearly average, at $4,997 against $4,373 across 2014-2023.

Why Deer Strike Repairs Cost More Than They Used To

Cars are now more expensive to fix due to the technology inside them.

More than half of animal-strike claims involve damage to the center of the front of the car. On most newer models, that’s exactly where the radar and cameras for automatic emergency braking and adaptive cruise control sit.

Replacing driver assistance parts after a minor front-end crash adds an average of $1,540 to the bill, on top of the bodywork.

“A deer strike is nearly always a hit to the front of the car, and what you can see is rarely the whole story. Behind the bumper you have the radiator, the air conditioning condenser, and the headlights, and on most cars built in the last few years, the radar and camera that run the emergency braking.” Luke Oswald, automotive specialist at Wheels Away

What a Deer Strike Repair Bill Can Include

What the bill can includeTypical cost
Average insurance payout per animal-strike claim, 2014 to 2023 $4,373
Average payout per animal-strike claim in November, 2014 to 2023 $4,997
Average payout per animal-strike claim, 2023 (latest available) $5,980
Front radar sensor (emergency braking, adaptive cruise) $500 to $1,300
Front camera sensor (not including the windshield) $600 to $800
Windshield camera sensor (lane keeping, pedestrian detection) $900 to $1,200
Side mirror with camera $740 to $1,600
Front or rear parking sensors $300 to $1,000
Driver assistance parts in a minor front-end repair (average) $1,540

Does Car Insurance Cover Hitting a Deer?

Usually yes, but only if you have the right cover. Whether you pay for the damage yourself often comes down to one line on your policy.

Comprehensive vs Collision: Which Covers a Deer Strike?

Hitting an animal is normally covered by comprehensive insurance, not collision. Comprehensive is optional: no state requires drivers to carry it. Check your policy and your deductible before you need them.

What if You Only Have Liability Insurance?

Liability-only insurance covers damage you cause to other people and their property, not your own car. Drivers on liability-only cover, which is common on older cars that are owned outright, will usually have to pay for deer-strike repairs themselves.

What Happens if You Swerve to Avoid a Deer?

Swerving brings its own problems. If you miss the deer but hit a tree, a guardrail, or another car, it will typically be treated as a collision claim instead. That can carry a different deductible and may be treated as at fault. It’s also more dangerous: swerving is how a fixable front-end repair turns into a rollover or a head-on crash.

Will Hitting a Deer Total My Car?

On an older car, it can. Insurers declare a car a total loss when the repairs cost more than a set share of its value. The exact value can vary by state. Many states use a 75% threshold, so at the 2023 average payout of $5,980, a single deer strike would be enough to total any car worth less than about $8,000.

Total Loss Thresholds by State

StateTotal loss rule
Wisconsin70% of the car’s value
West Virginia, Alabama, Tennessee, Louisiana75% of the car’s value
Montana, GeorgiaTotal loss formula: repairs plus salvage value exceed the car’s value

What to Do If You Hit a Deer: 8 Steps

Deer strikes are frightening and can happen in an instant. Knowing what to do in the moment can help you protect your safety, your life and your insurance claim.

  1. Brake firmly and stay in your lane. Don’t swerve if you can avoid it. Hitting the deer is usually safer than leaving the road or crossing into oncoming traffic.
  2. Pull over somewhere safe and turn on your hazard lights. Check that everyone in the car is OK. Call 911 if anyone is hurt or the animal is blocking the road.
  3. Keep your distance from the deer. An injured deer can kick out, so don’t try to move it or check on it.
  4. Photograph the damage, the scene and the road. Note exactly where it happened and what time. This helps with your insurance claim.
  5. Check whether you need to report it to the police. Rules vary by state, and some thresholds are low: $500 of damage in Georgia and Louisiana, $1,000 in Montana and Wisconsin, and $1,500 in Tennessee, where a written report is due within 20 days.
  6. Check the car before driving on. Look for leaks, broken lights, and warning lights on the dash. Coolant on the ground or a climbing temperature gauge means it shouldn’t be driven. If in doubt, get it towed.
  7. Call your insurer. Ask whether the claim falls under comprehensive or collision, and check your deductible.
  8. Get a written repair estimate and compare it with what the car is worth before agreeing to any work.

How to Avoid Hitting a Deer: Expert Tips

Although it’s not possible to completely eliminate your chances of a deer strike, you can give yourself more time to react. Luke Oswald, automotive specialist at Wheels Away, shares his advice below.

  • Be most alert at dawn and dusk. Deer are most active then, and in November that lines up almost exactly with the drive to and from work.
  • If one deer crosses, expect another. Deer rarely travel alone, so slow right down after the first one passes.
  • Slow down on rural two-lane roads. Winding routes through woods and hills give you little warning, and a few extra seconds are what let you stop.
  • Use your high beams when there’s nothing coming the other way, and keep scanning the edges of the road.
  • Brake, don’t swerve. Swerving is how a fixable front-end repair turns into a rollover or a head-on crash.
  • Know your local season. November is the peak nationally, but in states like Alabama and Louisiana, deer stay active into February.
Luke Oswald, End of Life Vehicle Specialist at Wheels Away
Luke Oswald, Automotive Specialist at Wheels Away

Is Your Car Worth Fixing After Hitting a Deer?

On a newer car with comprehensive cover, the answer is usually simple: you claim and get it fixed. On an older car you own outright, especially one on liability-only insurance, a deer strike can easily cost more than the car is worth.

Before you agree to repair, weigh up three things:

  • The repair estimate, including any sensors behind the bumper
  • What the car is worth today, as it was before the strike
  • Your cover: whether you have comprehensive coverage, and how much your deductible is

FAQs

According to a 2026 analysis by Wheels Away, West Virginia has the worst odds, with drivers facing a 1 in 46 chance of an animal collision claim. Montana has the most claims for its size, at 1,422 per 100,000 residents. Pennsylvania has the most claims in total, at around 142,300 a year.

Most deer collisions happen in November, with claims in this month running at twice the yearly average, according to 2026 research by Wheels Away.

October and December are the next riskiest months. Collectively, these three months account for around 41% of animal-collision claims, as deer are breeding and on the move. In states where deer stay active into February, like Alabama and Louisiana, the risk lasts into the new year.

Collisions are most likely to occur at dawn or dusk, when deer are most active. In late fall, when the clocks have gone back, those hours line up with the morning and evening commute, which can make November a particularly risky month for collisions. Take extra care on rural roads at these times, use your high beams when nothing is coming the other way, and slow down if you see one deer, because others are often close behind.

Usually yes, as long as you have comprehensive cover. Hitting an animal is normally a comprehensive claim, not a collision claim. If you have liability-only, you will usually need to pay for the repairs yourself. If you swerve and hit something else, such as a tree, a guardrail, or another car, it will typically be treated as a collision claim, which can carry a different deductible and may count as at fault.

It depends on what state you’re in and how much damage there is. Most states require a report if anyone is injured or killed, or if the damage exceeds a set amount. This threshold varies by state. In Georgia and Louisiana, this is $500. In Montana and Wisconsin, it’s $1,000, and in Tennessee, it’s $1,500. Call 911 if anyone is injured or if the animal is blocking the road, and check your state’s rules if you’re not sure.

It can, especially on an older car. Many states use a 75% total loss threshold, which means a car is written off once the repairs cost more than three-quarters of its value.

How We Built the Animal Collision Risk Index

The Wheels Away Animal Collision Risk Index scores all 50 states and Washington DC out of 100, using 11 measures from State Farm, the FHWA, IIHS, HLDI, the US Census, state wildlife agencies and Google search data. Each measure is scored from 0 (the lowest state) to 1 (the highest), weighted, and added together. The higher the score, the higher the risk.

The odds of a claim and the share of driving on rural roads carry the most weight, at 20% each. Rates per driver or per person count for more than raw totals, so big states don’t top the list just for being big.

Repair bills use HLDI’s average animal-strike claim of $4,373 (2014 to 2023), so they’re likely conservative. State Farm’s figures cover all animals, not just deer. Checked November 2026.